I saw Transamerica this weekend.
There were a bunch of places, from the very beginning, where I thought they got things exactly right. I sat there nodding and thinking that I knew exactly how she felt.
But I was really frustrated by Bree, the main character.
I’m fairly girly myself, I’m all about pink and pretty shoes and hair ribbons and all that stuff, but I don’t think that means that I have to be useless and prissy. I would have been frustrated with Bree, male or female, trans or not, because I don’t have any patience for people who won’t do something because there hands might get dirty, or because people of their gender don’t do those kind of things.
I spent the whole movie waiting to see what it was that made Bree strong, what made Bree special, the thing that transcended gender and existed in her no matter how she was presenting. I would have been happy with something like the car breaking down and Bree grabbing a wrench and fixing it, something to say that basic human competence is not related to gender.
Living into a female identity doesn’t mean that I have to forget that I was a welder and a carpenter, just as living into a male identity didn’t mean that I couldn’t discuss Oscar fashions with my mother.
She talked at one point about the cultures that valued us as “two-spirit people” but it was hard for me to see that she had much spirit at all.
It seemed for her to live into her feminine identity, she had to adopt all of the cultural stereotypes that go along with being a woman: overly fastidious, timid, hobbling along in high heels, made helpless by an overly elaborate manicure. (I was impressed by how she was able to keep that manicure immaculate through the entire trip. It’s usually only about half an hour before I have scratched my nail polish)
But, I think one of the great things about being trans is that I have the opportunity to pick and choose which gender roles and expectations I will live into and which ones I will ignore.
My limited experience in the trans community makes me think that I may not be typical, though. I have gotten the impression that the driving passion for many trans-women is the desire to “pass.” Everything revolves around reaching the point where they will pass completely as a woman. In the movie, Bree implies that part of her motivation to have SRS is so that she will be able to pass utterly, even to the point of a gynecological exam.
I’m really not driven by that urge. What’s more important for me is to have the freedom, confidence and courage to not pass. I want to be able to be me, whatever that may mean, and I want to learn to be happy with whatever that means, not to spend my whole life wishing for more.