Tip Jar

Change is good

Tip Jar

« The Final Version... | Main | Why alone? »

January 24, 2006

Comments

maveet

3AM a couple nights ago I found myself thinking of you, wanting to write something in your comments. I've been doing a lot of blogsploring, and compiling my own blogroll. I added you. Somehow i was captivated by your whole project: in-process re identity, body, career, and writing about it in a public forum. What, thought I, could I write other than aknowledging your journey, wishing your well? So why bother?
Then I came back, read again, and realized if i was serious, I'd have to ask, "WTF are you doing working so hard to be accepted by a community, both your immediate and your larger one, that basically despise what you represent, hence who you are?"

Well, it's highly possible (likely, even) that I haven't a clue about your communities' feelings about you, to say nothing about your motivations. To me your gender transformation, your need to "get her words out" are courageous and aknowledging of your deepest inner urgings. But why aren't you somewhere there are like-minded and/or supportive folks? Why is it 6 or 11 years since intimacy, or even closeness? Like, I'm not intending to grill you, nor do I need (!) answers. these are just questions that went through my 3AM wonderings, and are still there each time I see your site.

And is Meghan going to become an accepted part of the church hierarchy? Wouldn't you be better off at some sort of LGBT congregation? And I'll stop before I address the whole issue of religion, christians and god-botherers on the planet, and how good they've always fucked it up, particularly for women. just sayin'.

welderasf

Good questions, and good points, I may address some of them in future posts, I always do better when answering questions than I do just trying to think of something to write.

As far as "why am I involved with the church?" I imagine that if I had done things in a different order, if I had been out first I would probably not gone seeking a home in the church.

But, I went to the church first, before I even said the word "Transgender" to myself, let alone to anyone else. Now, the church and my faith are central in my life and I need to find a way to make all the parts of my life work together, not just walk away from one because it's inconvenient.

Staying with the PC(USA)is another issue. I would probably have a much easier path to follow if I went to the UCC or MCC churches, but the PC(USA)is my home, and my families home. I love being Presbyterian, and I am a huge Presbyterian polity wonk. I don't want to leave.

Also, especially when it comes from someone inside the PC(USA), the question "wouldn't it be easier if you went to another denomination?" sounds a lot like, "wouldn't it be easier if you just sat at the back of the bus?"

I'll work on other answers during the day and try to post some of my thoughts. I have to start in on a 5 day take home exegesis exam this afternoon and it will help me to have something else to think about as I work on it.

(I know that doesn't make much sense, but it reflects how my brain works, I do much better when I don't try to focus on just one thing.)

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment